Holiday Returns Just Got Trickier (and Pricier)

Remember when returning that fugly sweater from Aunt Edna was as easy as dropping it in the mail, free of charge? 👋📭 We might soon kiss those days goodbye…just like the days when we used to “go online.” Let’s get you to bed, grandma. 👵🏼🖥️

This holiday season, more stores are adding return fees, shrinking their return windows, and running a whole Spanish Inquisition before they take your stuff back. 😱The good news? A little know-how can help you dodge the fees and steer clear of the BS! 💡

Here’s Five Fast Facts on how holiday returns are changing:

  1. 📈 Hefty Headache - Shoppers sent back an estimated $850 billion in goods in 2025, nearly double the amount from 2020. About 19% of all online purchases get returned. Each return costs a store roughly 30% of the item’s value to process, which explains why they’re cracking down.
  1. 🥵 Return Burn - Roughly 68% of retailers now tack a fee onto at least some returns, up from 43% just five years ago. For example, Macy’s charges $9.99 to mail back an item and Gap charges $6, unless you join their free loyalty programs.
  1. 🪤 The Walk-In Trap - Plenty of retailers that charge for mailed returns, like J.Crew, JCPenney, and Anthropologie, let you bring items back to a store for free. Just know that stores are betting you’ll grab something else while you’re there, so go in with a plan (or blinders on). 
  1. 💆 7th Inning Stretch - A small-but-mighty win: many big retailers stretch their windows for the holidays, giving gifts time to land under the tree. Macy’s takes holiday purchases back through 1/31, well past its usual 30 days.
  1. 🏅 For the Win - Target and Walmart still offer free returns by mail or in store with roughly 90-day windows, Amazon has tons of free drop-off spots, and Quince gives you a full year. When returns elsewhere might be tricky, shopping with one of these retailers can save you the hassle.

🔥Bottom line: The era of no-questions-asked returns is becoming a thing of the past. Before you hit that buy button, check the store’s return policy. Lean toward in-store returns to dodge mail fees and do your homework so the gift fits the first time. After all, the best return is the one you never have to make!

‍

What’s the worst gift you ever received?

‍

Let us know by connecting with us on Facebook and Instagram! Also, remember to share this newsletter with your friends & coworkers!

‍

Btw, If you’ve read this far and haven’t yet signed up for the weekly Paycheckology newsletter, CLICK HERE!

‍