When The Clash asked, “should I stay or should I go,” were they talking about your day job? 🤔🎸 For years, bouncing every couple of years was the way score a fatter paycheck, while sticking around made you a sucker. 💸 Now, that math is getting a second look.
These days, whether loyalty or leaving wins comes down to two things: how much you already make and what generation you were born into. 👀 Time to clock in and crunch the numbers. ⏰
Here’s Five Fast Facts on the great stay-or-go debate:
- 💼 Loyalty Leads - Here's a surprise for the job-hoppers. The top 5% of earners who stayed at their jobs got raises of almost 10%. The ones who switched got a much smaller raise, only about 1% to 3%. For top earners, staying put now wins.
- 🦘 Jump Scare - For everyone else, the old advice still works. Lower, middle, and higher earners (everyone but the top 5%) got a bigger raise after taxes when they switched jobs. If you’re not runnin’ with the big dogs yet, a new job can still mean more money.
- 🎰 Still a Gamble - That being said, about half the people who stayed got no raise in early 2026. For those who switched, 44% got nothing either, and some even lost pay. The gap between stayers and switchers is the smallest it has been in seven years, and ADP found the January difference was just 1.9%.
- 🏗️ Hard Hat Bonus - Switching still pays big in certain job sectors. In construction, mining, and natural resources, workers who switched saw pay go up 6.6%. Workers who stayed got 5.6%. Bosses in these fields really need workers, so jumping helps.
- 🚼 Young and Restless - Gen Z switched jobs more than twice as often as Gen X, and it worked. Their pay grew 4x faster than the people who stayed. Millennials who switched did well too, with pay growing about twice as fast as stayers. But Gen X and Boomers who switched saw their pay stay flat or drop, while those who stayed earned more.
🔥Bottom line: The days of always quitting for more money are slowing down, but staying or leaving pays off based on your age and how much you make. Think it through before you quit, because a new job isn’t always the better deal. Want to know if your raise is keeping up with rising prices? Check out this article on where your grocery money goes.
Planning on a job hop?
Let us know by connecting with us on Facebook and Instagram! Also, remember to share this newsletter with your friends & coworkers!
Btw, If you’ve read this far and haven’t yet signed up for the weekly Paycheckology newsletter, CLICK HERE!
