You Can't Tax Your Way To Prosperity

Seattle might be famous for its rainy weather and giant space needle, but lately, the city is experiencing a different kind of storm: a mass exodus of businesses. We talked before about the Laffer Curve, and while there's real debate about the specific levels of taxation that work (or don't), the concept is completely sound logic. Now it's time to get into some real life examples, starting with Washington State.

Here are Five Fast Facts to drive home the point that you can't tax your way to prosperity:

  1. 👋 Flippant Faux Pas - Socialist Mayor Katie Wilson was asked if she had concerns about increased taxes driving away the wealthy and businesses. She laughed off the question and said, "...like, bye!" while telling everyone to stop buying Starbucks, then joined a picket line against the coffee giant.
  1. 👀 Be Careful What You Wish For - The Seattle-born global cultural icon took her up on her response and said, "Hold my espresso" while announcing plans to move its entire global headquarters to Nashville, proving that even caffeine can be weaponized.
  1. 📝 Flame War - Former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz roasted both Seattle and Wilson in the Wall Street Journal, pointing out that Seattle is drowning in problems like a slow tech hiring, bad public-school results, chronic homelessness and drug usage, and budget deficits; hostility that drives away job creators and those who pay the sky high taxes is, to say the least, stupid (our word, not his...but we stand by it).
  1. 📉 Shedding Jobs - Seattle's downtown area suffered a major economic faceplant in 2025, losing 13k jobs in a single year, which is the sharpest drop the city has seen since everyone was stuck at home binging The Tiger King during the pandemic.
  1. 🏢 Unreal Estate - The local skyscrapers are quickly turning into very expensive, high-tech ghost towns because the office vacancy rate has climbed to a shocking 30%, meaning nearly one out of every three desks is currently occupied only by dust bunnies. Real estate values are tanking so hard that even some of downtown's most prominent towers have lost more than half of their tax value since 2021.

🔥Bottom line: In the end, running a city on socialist slogans works great until the people who fund those programs decide to leave. Mayor Wilson backpedaled, admitting that calling for a boycott against her own city's most famous global brand "caused more harm than good," but local business leaders warn that Seattle is already at a dangerous tipping point. Other local politicians are concerned because they see that non-profit workers, local artisans, and coffee shop baristas cannot generate the hundreds of millions of dollars needed to pay the city's welfare bills. It's like the economic reality equivalent of Eeli Tolvanen smashing socialism against the boards - you can't tax your way to prosperity!

What do you think about this kerfuffle?

Let us know by connecting with us on Facebook and Instagram! Also, remember to share this newsletter with your friends & coworkers!

BTW, If you’ve read this far and haven’t yet signed up for the weekly Paycheckology newsletter, CLICK HERE!